|
After three years of tough negotiations, the United Farm Workers
of America, AFL-CIO (UFW) and a coalition of the nation's
major agricultural employers have reached a historic bipartisan
compromise on immigration and labor reforms. Several members of
Congress worked with the parties to achieve this compromise including,
Representatives Howard Berman (D-Ca) and Chris Cannon (R-UT), and
Senators Larry Craig (R-ID) and Edward Kennedy (D-MA).
The compromise, if enacted, will (1) create an "earned
legalization" program enabling undocumented farm workers
to earn legal permanent status if they have been working in the
U.S. and continue to work in agriculture for a period of time; and
(2) reform the existing agricultural guest worker program, the H-2A
temporary foreign agricultural worker program.
This compromise only applies to workers in the agricultural industry
and does not address the needs of other undocumented workers. While
this is a historic compromise, it is only the first step to broader
reform of our current immigration system.
Like any compromise, each of the parties made significant concessions.
Most notably, farm worker advocates were able to achieve industry
support for a program that will enable an estimated 500,000 undocumented
workers to become legal permanent residents... If enacted, this
concept of "earned legalization" will become
law for the first time ever. These workers, who have been laboring
in one of our country's most dangerous and lowest paying
occupations, will no longer need to live in fear of deportation
for demanding better wages and working conditions or challenging
illegal employment practices. Moreover, the immediate families of
these workers, if living in the United States, will not be subject
to deportation.
The growers, in turn, obtained a freeze of the adverse effect wage
rate ("AEWR") for three years, and if Congress
fails to enact a new wage rate, the AEWR will thereafter be increased
annually by the change in the consumer price index, capped at 4%
per year. The compromise also streamlines the process for employers
who seek to bring in foreign workers, while providing additional
protections for those workers.
Attached is summary of the compromise.
AGRICULTURE FARMWORKER COMPROMISE SUMMARY
Earned Legalization Program for Farm Workers. The legalization
program will offer many undocumented farm workers and H-2A guest
workers the opportunity to become legal immigrants. To become part
of the program, a worker must demonstrate that he or she performed
agricultural work for 575 hours or 100 work days, whichever is less,
during any 12 consecutive months between March 1, 2002 and August
31, 2003. Agricultural employment includes field and livestock employment
but generally excludes work performed in meat and poultry processing
plants (as defined in the Fair Labor Standards Act and the Internal
Revenue Code).
Application Process. The application period would begin
in the middle of 2004 and last 18 months. To reduce fraud, applications
would have to be filed through a government-approved organization
("qualified designated entity" or QDE)
or a licensed attorney. QDEs could be a farm labor organization,
employer association or organization with substantial immigration
experience. Legal assistance programs funded by the federal Legal
Services Corporation would be permitted to assist applicants. The
Department of Homeland Security and State Department also would
establish a procedure for applying from outside the United States.
The application procedure is designed to ensure applicants have
actually performed agricultural work while recognizing the difficulty
applicants will have in securing evidence of their employment, which
ordinarily would have been performed without authorization under
the immigration laws and frequently "off the books."
Once the farm worker proves he or she performed the work and otherwise
meets the standards of U.S. immigration laws, he or she would be
granted a temporary resident immigration status. Such temporary
residents would be treated as immigrants and will be able to work
in any employment, when not working in agriculture, and to cross
the border. During the period of temporary resident status, the
spouse and minor children of the worker, who are living in the United
States will be protected from deportation is they too are undocumented,
but will not qualify for employment authorization. All applicable
federal and state labor laws would apply.
Requirements to Become a Legal Permanent Resident. To become
a permanent resident immigrant, the worker would have to meet the
following additional requirements:
> Work in agriculture for at least 360 days in the six-year
period beginning September 1, 2003; and
> At least 240 of those work days in agriculture must
occur during the three-year period beginning September 1, 2003 through
August 31, 2006; and
> Of those work days, in at least three years, the person
must have worked at least 75 days in agriculture.
Credit for this future-work-requirement will be given for employment
lost because the worker has been fired without just cause or has
lost work due to occupational injury or illness.
H-2A Guest Worker Program. The current H2A program (which
replaced the infamous "bracero" program
of the 1940's and 50's) allows agricultural
employers to hire approximately 42,000 foreign farm workers annually
on temporary work visas. The compromise will streamline the H-2A
guest worker program by reducing employers' paperwork
requirements and government oversight. Instead of a "labor
certification" program, the H-2A program will rely
on "labor attestation," similar to the
H-1B program.
Adverse Effect Wage Rates. The H-2A program's
adverse effect wage rates, which are issued annually on a state-by-state
basis and operate as a minimum wage for H-2A employers, would be
frozen for three years at the levels in effect in January 2003.
Presently, the wage rates are based on regional wage surveys performed
by the U.S. Department of Agriculture. During this three-year period,
two studies would be performed regarding appropriate measures for
the H-2A wage rates. If Congress does not act within the three years,
then the H-2A wage rates would be increased annually beginning in
2006 based on the previous one year's change in consumer
price index. H-2A employers would still be required to pay the highest
of the frozen adverse effect wage rate, the local "prevailing
wage" for the particular job, and the state or federal
minimum wage.
Additional Rights for H-2A Workers. For the first time,
H-2A guest workers would have the right to enforce the terms of
their employment contracts in federal courts. While citizens and
immigrant farm workers are covered by the Migrant and Seasonal Agricultural
Worker Protection Act ("AWPA"), the principal
federal employment law for farm workers, AWPA excludes H-2A guest
workers. Although H-2A guest workers would not be covered by AWPA,
they would have better remedies available to them than before, without
losing any other rights under state or federal labor laws.
Failure to meet these requirements and apply for permanent status
would result in a termination of temporary resident status. Workers
must apply for permanent resident status no later than August 31,
2010. Conviction of a felony or three misdemeanors also would terminate
the temporary resident status.
Immediate Family of Farm Workers. Special procedures exist
for family members of participating farm workers. Once the farm
worker is granted temporary resident status, the immediate family
members who lack authorized immigration status may not be deported
during this legalization process. However, the family members who
lack authorized immigration status may not be employed (unless they
qualify in their own right to participate in the "earned
legalization" program. Once the farm worker fulfills
the requirements of the "earned legalization"
program and receives permanent resident status, the immediate family
members also will be granted immigration status as long as they
meet other requirements under immigration law.
|